What steps are taken when a formal complaint is lodged with a university over the actions of a student or a teaching faculty member? Allegations of wrongdoing can have far-reaching repercussions, going far beyond the obvious and immediate potential for the termination of studies and the ramifications for reputation; for the alleged perpetrator, these repercussions might have career-limiting or possibly even criminal implications.
Getting things correctly is a need for everyone that is involved. When looking into allegations of unethical behavior, universities are not required to adhere to any particular scheme, and they are not given a predetermined set of protocols they must always use.
No single definition can be used to refer to non-academic misbehavior. In most cases, institutions will use a non-exhaustive definition of misbehavior since this is the safer option, given that it is impossible to anticipate every important act or omission. The concept will frequently contain uncomplicated occurrences, such as low-level damage to property or anti-social behavior, for example.
A Fair Procedure
A procedure that is fair will have elements such as:
It is important that the student who is being accused of engaging in inappropriate behavior be notified of the allegation as soon as possible, with specific reference to any applicable rules or standards of conduct, as well as any evidence that is being relied on.
It is recommended that the investigation be carried out by a member of staff who is unaffected by the facts that have emerged as a result of the allegation and who will not later be involved in any role that involves decision-making.
In the event that it is decided to move forward with a disciplinary hearing, the procedure should address a number of issues. These issues include the timeframes for the production of documentary evidence, the order of proceedings, the role of the panel members, whether or not the student can be accompanied or represented, whether or not witnesses can be called, etc.
The consequences for unethical behavior should be laid out precisely, and their application should be in accordance with the seriousness of the transgression.
In the event that misbehavior is discovered, mitigation should be considered.
Any decision made ought to be accompanied by an explanation in writing.
A right of appeal ought to be made available to the students.
How compliance works
Because of the contractual nature of the connection that exists between the student and the institution, there may be a contractual foundation for a disciplinary procedure to be carried out in a particular manner. A student will have the ability to exercise their rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 because they are considered to be consumers. For instance, one could argue that section 49, the right to exercise reasonable care and skill, applies to the process of disciplining employees.
The connection between student and university is also governed by public law, which means that decisions made by an institution within the context of the disciplinary procedure may be subject to judicial scrutiny.
What Universities should consider when Reviewing their policies
Accessibility, clarity, proportionality, punctuality, justice, independence, confidentiality, and improving the student experience are the fundamental tenets of excellent practice. These tenets should be adhered to at all times.
Throughout the entirety of the disciplinary procedure, the rules of natural justice should be adhered to.
The procedures should make it abundantly apparent what behaviors can be considered inappropriate, the appropriate steps to take, and the potential consequences for a student.
There should be processes in place to deal with inappropriate behavior on the part of students and employees alike.
The use of mediation or conciliation as an alternative to more formal action may be appropriate in some circumstances.
Contact Us
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call us and we will see how we can best help you.
Enquiry : 0207 041 6069
Emergency: 07852 226 702
33 St. James’s Square
London SW1Y 4JS